Skip to content
CalculatorFly

Rent vs Buy Calculator

Enter the home price, your mortgage and the rent for a similar place. See who comes out ahead after the years you plan to stay, and the year buying starts to win.

Buying

Ownership costs

Renting

Your plans

After 7 years
-
-Break-even year
-Cost to own, month 1
-Cost to rent, month 1
-Cash to buy (down + closing)
Net worth from buying versus renting, by year
Buying: home equity after selling costs + savingsRenting: invested savings

Buying, over 7 years

Mortgage payment (P&I)
-
Total paid to own (incl. upfront)
-
Mortgage interest paid
-
Home value at the end
-
Selling costs
-
Loan balance left
-
Equity when you sell
-
Net cost of buying
-

Renting, over 7 years

Total rent and insurance
-
Renter's savings at the end
-
Buyer's net worth at the end
-
Net cost of renting
-

Net cost = cash spent minus what you own at the end. Both sides spend the same cash each month: whoever pays less invests the difference, and the renter also invests the down payment and closing costs. No tax on investment gains or the home sale. An estimate, not financial advice.

Year by year

Costs, equity and net cost for each year
YearOwn costRent costHome valueEquityNet cost buyNet cost rentAhead

How to use the rent vs buy calculator

Enter the price of the home you are considering, your down payment, mortgage rate and term, then the rent for a comparable place. Adjust property tax, insurance, HOA dues, maintenance and closing costs to match your area, and set how many years you expect to stay. The result shows which choice leaves you with more money after that many years, the first year buying pulls ahead, and a year-by-year table. Try changing the years you stay: it is usually the single biggest factor.

How the comparison works

The calculator runs month by month. A buyer pays the down payment and closing costs, then the mortgage payment, PMI if the down payment is under 20% (until the loan falls to 78% of the price), property tax and maintenance as a share of the home's current value, insurance and HOA dues. A renter pays rent, which rises once a year, and renters insurance.

To compare fairly, both people spend the same money. The renter invests the cash the buyer put into the down payment and closing costs, and every month whoever has the lower bill invests the difference at your investment return. At the end:

Buyer's net worth = home value − selling costs − loan balance + buyer's savings
Renter's net worth = renter's savings
Net cost = cash spent − net worth

The break-even year is the first year in which the buyer's net worth is at least the renter's. Taxes on investment gains and on the home sale are left out (most sellers owe none thanks to the $250,000 or $500,000 home sale exclusion). The optional deduction subtracts mortgage interest × your marginal rate each month, which overstates the benefit if you would take the standard deduction anyway.

Worked example

A $400,000 home with 20% down ($80,000) and 3% closing costs ($12,000) needs $92,000 in cash. The 30-year mortgage on $320,000 at 6.5% is $2,022.62 a month, and with 1.1% property tax, $1,800 insurance and 1% maintenance, owning costs $2,872.62 in month one against $2,215 to rent ($2,200 rent plus $15 insurance). With 3% home value growth, 3% rent increases and a 6% return on savings, after 7 years the home is worth $491,950 and the loan is down to $289,332, leaving $173,101 of equity after 6% selling costs. The renter's invested savings have grown to $194,070, so renting is about $20,969 ahead. Stay longer and buying wins from year 12; turn on the mortgage interest deduction at a 22% rate and it wins from year 6.

FAQ

Is renting just throwing money away?

No. Much of an owner's early payments is interest, property tax, insurance and maintenance, which you never get back either. Buying builds equity, but closing and selling costs often take several years of appreciation and principal to recover. Renting can come out ahead for shorter stays, especially if you invest the money you would otherwise put into a down payment.

What investment return should I use?

Use what you realistically expect to earn on money you would otherwise put into the house. A diversified stock fund has historically returned around 6% to 7% a year after inflation over long periods, but with big swings; a high-yield savings account or CDs earn less. If you would not actually invest the difference, use a low rate.

What costs do buyers often forget?

Closing costs (typically 2% to 5% of the price), maintenance and repairs (a common rule of thumb is 1% of the home's value a year), rising property tax and insurance, HOA dues and special assessments, and selling costs of around 5% to 6% when you move.

Is my information sent anywhere?

No. CalculatorFly runs every calculation on your device with WebAssembly. Nothing you enter is uploaded or stored. Results are estimates based on your assumptions, not financial advice.